Physical Geography Research

Physical Geography Research

Peer Review Process

Peer Review and Publication Process

Physical Geography Research

Updated: 10 October 2026

Physical Geography Research (JPHGR) uses pre-publication, double-blind peer review. Author identities are withheld from reviewers and reviewer identities from authors in the review process. Blinding supports impartial assessment; conflicts and ethical concerns are also managed separately.

1. Submission and initial assessment

Submit through the journal system, with author details in a separate title-page file and an anonymised review manuscript. The editorial team assesses scope, completeness, originality, presentation and similarity concerns. A manuscript may be returned for missing requirements or rejected before external review when it is unsuitable. Similarity screening is assessed in context and does not itself establish misconduct.

2. Reviewer selection and assessment

Suitable manuscripts are assessed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers disclose conflicts, preserve confidentiality and evaluate the contribution, methods, evidence, clarity and limitations. An unconflicted editor handles submissions by editors or board members; an author-editor does not select reviewers, handle the review or decide the submission.

3. Revision and decision

The editor considers the reviews and scientific evidence and may request an additional independent review if needed. Decisions may be rejection, minor revision, major revision or acceptance. Authors receive the decision and relevant review comments and submit a point-by-point response with revisions. A revision may be returned to reviewers. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision; the editor has final responsibility.

4. Acceptance and production

After scientific acceptance, author-identifying details are restored for the final publication version. Publication charges are requested according to the author guidelines. Editing, typesetting and author proof checks follow. Errors affecting scientific meaning or authorship must be reported to the editor; changes requiring reassessment are reviewed before publication.

Timing and tracking

Initial assessment, external review, revision and acceptance are separate stages. Authors track the case through their account. Recorded website statistics do not guarantee a decision date; time depends on suitability, reviewer availability, revisions and any integrity investigation.

Complaints, appeals and related information

Send a reasoned complaint or appeal with the manuscript identifier and evidence to jphgr@ut.ac.ir. The journal acknowledges receipt and initiates action within three working days, excluding the day of receipt; independent assessment and completion depend on the case. See the ethics and appeals policy, author guidelines and editorial board.