Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

The journal of Physical Geography Research follows a rigorous peer review process to ensure the highest quality and integrity of the articles it publishes. The journal upholds international publication standards and adheres to ethical guidelines set forth by the Committee on Ethics in Publication (COPE). Furthermore, it complies with the executive regulations of the law on preventing and dealing with fraud in scientific works, affirming its commitment to maintaining the integrity and ethics of the publication process.

The peer review process of Physical Geography Research is conducted in a double-blinded manner, where the identities of both the reviewers and the authors are kept confidential. This approach ensures impartiality and eliminates potential biases, allowing for an objective evaluation of the manuscripts. The anonymity of the reviewers and authors fosters an environment where the review is carried out without prejudice.

Upon submission, manuscripts undergo an initial assessment to determine their alignment with the scopes and format of the journal. Manuscripts that meet these criteria proceed to the peer review stage. Expert reviewers, who are well-versed in their respective fields, meticulously evaluate the scientific quality, methodology, clarity, and adherence to publication standards of the manuscripts. They provide constructive feedback and recommendations to improve the research, ensuring the rigor and validity of the findings.

Following the completion of the peer review process, the Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on whether the manuscripts will be accepted, revised, or rejected. This decision is based on the reviewers' evaluations and the overall suitability of the manuscripts for publication in Physical Geography Research. Manuscripts that are approved for publication enter the production process, where they undergo editing, formatting, and preparation for online publication.

By maintaining a robust peer review process, Physical Geography Research ensures the quality, reliability, and credibility of the articles it publishes. This commitment to rigorous evaluation and feedback contributes to the advancement of scientific knowledge in the field of physical geography. The journal strives to provide a platform for high-quality research that fosters innovation, promotes interdisciplinary collaboration, and informs decision-making in the discipline.

Flowchart of the peer review process of the Journal of Physical Geography Research.